Public School Caught Forcing Islam Indoctrination on Students: Thomas More Law Center Takes Fight to U.S. Supreme Court

 

This case is bigger than one school in New Jersey. If the lower court’s ruling stands, school districts across America will have a green light to push Islam.

In 2017, seventh-graders at Chatham Middle School in New Jersey walked into what was supposed to be a simple World Cultures class. Instead, they were hit with blatant religious recruitment for Islam, paid for by taxpayer dollars and required for a passing grade.The materials were shocking:

• A five-minute video titled “Intro to Islam” declared as undisputed fact that “Allah is the one God,” “Muhammad is the last and final Messenger of God,” and the Quran is the “perfect guide for humanity.”
• The same video closed with an on-screen prayer: “May God help us all find the true faith, Islam. Ameen.”
• Students were then handed worksheets forcing them to fill in the blank for the Shahada, the Islamic declaration of faith: “There is no God but ____ and ____ is his messenger.”

No similar videos or worksheets were ever shown for Christianity, Judaism, Hinduism, or any other religion. Just Islam, presented not as one belief among many, but as the truth students were expected to accept.
When Christian mother Libby Hilsenrath discovered what her 12-year-old son was being taught, she went to the school board. They ignored her. She sued. Federal courts, including the Third Circuit Court of Appeals, ruled in favor of the school district, claiming this aggressive proselytizing was just “education.”
Now the Thomas More Law Center has taken the case to the United States Supreme Court, asking the justices to reverse that dangerous decision.

The Thomas More Law Center is making sure the highest court in the land hears that message loud and clear. Get updates here: Thomas More Law Center

The petition argues that forcing children to memorize and recite a religious conversion statement in a mandatory public-school class is textbook government endorsement of religion, exactly what the First Amendment forbids. It points to the Supreme Court’s 2022 Kennedy v. Bremerton decision, which told courts to look at “history and tradition” when deciding Establishment Clause cases. Under any honest historical reading, public schools have never been allowed to act as missionaries for one faith.
This case is bigger than one school in New Jersey. If the lower court’s ruling stands, school districts across America will have a green light to push Islam, or any other religion, while telling objecting parents to sit down and be quiet. Classrooms could become recruitment centers, and the fundamental right of parents to direct their children’s religious upbringing, a right the Supreme Court has called “deeply rooted in our history”, would be gutted.
Parents send their kids to school to learn math, science, and history, not to be told which God they should worship. Yet that is exactly what Chatham Middle School did, and lower courts incredibly called it constitutional.
The Supreme Court now has the chance to slam the door on this overreach. Every parent in America should be watching. Your children’s Christian faith is not Islam to shape. 

All truths are easy to understand once they are discovered; the point is to discover them.-Galileo

Now You Know

Image: Lady Justice: https://www.freepik.com/free-ai-image/lady-justice-statue-front-courthouse-sunset_418993811.htm

Richard Grenell’s Hypocrisy Exposed: Firing a Christian for Faith While Trump Champions Religious Freedom

 

Grenell’s Thin Skin and Shady Past Unraveled Amid Kennedy Center Controversy

Floyd Brown’s recent firing from the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts by Richard Grenell is a glaring example of hypocrisy and cowardice, especially under the watch of President Donald Trump, who has consistently positioned himself as a defender of Christian values and religious liberty. Brown, a vocal Christian and political organizer, claims he was sacked just hours after CNN inquired about his past statements supporting traditional marriage—a move that reeks of Grenell caving to media pressure rather than standing firm on principle. This incident not only exposes Grenell’s shaky leadership but also raises questions about his alignment with Trump’s pro-Christian stance and his own checkered history. Let’s dig into the dirt on Grenell and unpack this scandal.

Brown’s post on X details how he was recruited as a Vice President at the Kennedy Center, only to be abruptly fired after refusing to renounce his Christian beliefs on marriage. He alleges Grenell demanded he recant his views or face termination, a claim that paints Grenell as spineless in the face of a potential CNN hit piece. This is particularly jarring given Trump’s public crackdown on those who target Christians. Trump has repeatedly vowed to protect religious freedom, emphasizing policies to safeguard Christians from discrimination and cultural erasure. His administration’s push to “Make Art Great Again” at the Kennedy Center, under Grenell’s leadership, was supposed to reflect these values. Yet, Grenell’s alleged decision to fire Brown for his faith directly contradicts Trump’s mission, revealing a disconnect that demands scrutiny.

I was fired yesterday by @RichardGrenell from the John F Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts. One month ago, I was recruited to join the Kennedy Center as a Vice President. My firing came approximately two hours after @CNN sent an email asking me to comment on my past…

— Floyd Brown (@floydbrown) May 29, 2025

Now, let’s get to the juicy stuff on Richard Grenell. A Trump loyalist appointed interim president of the Kennedy Center in February 2025, Grenell has a history that’s less than squeaky clean. His tenure as U.S. Ambassador to Germany (2018–2020) was marred by controversy, with critics accusing him of meddling in German domestic politics. He openly criticized Germany’s energy policies and threatened sanctions over the Nord Stream 2 pipeline, prompting calls from German officials for his expulsion. His brash style earned him few friends in diplomatic circles, with some labeling him a “diplomatic disaster.” Grenell’s brief stint as Acting Director of National Intelligence in 2020 also raised eyebrows when he declassified documents to push narratives favorable to Trump, a move critics slammed as politicizing intelligence.

At the Kennedy Center, Grenell’s leadership has been a lightning rod for criticism. He’s overseen a purge of staff and programming, firing nearly 40 employees, including Deborah Rutter, the center’s president for over a decade. Rutter and others have accused Grenell of mismanagement, with claims that the center was fiscally sound before his arrival. Grenell’s response? Baseless allegations of “fraud” against Rutter, which she vehemently denied, calling his attacks “malicious.” His restructuring has driven away artists like Yo-Yo Ma and Lin-Manuel Miranda, who canceled performances in protest of Trump’s takeover.

Grenell’s public feuds don’t stop there. He’s lashed out at “Les Misérables” actors for planning to boycott a performance Trump was set to attend, calling them “vapid and intolerant” and suggesting a blacklist for artists who refuse to perform. This tough-guy act crumbles when you consider his apparent panic over a CNN inquiry, firing Brown to avoid bad press. Posts on X highlight the outrage, with users like 

@GreenShades9 and @RichardAngwin slamming Grenell’s hypocrisy as a gay man who claims to champion diversity while allegedly punishing Brown for his Christian beliefs. Others, like @Dean_of_Numbers, call for Grenell’s firing and even prosecution, labeling his actions a “felony deprivation of rights.”

Richard Grenell is anti-traditional Christian values, like marriage, because it affects HIM, otherwise he wouldn't have fired Floyd Brown; typical Republican hypocrisy.

— Sterling (@GreenShades9) May 29, 2025

Then there’s Grenell’s cozy new gig on Live Nation’s board, announced in May 2025 amid a DOJ antitrust probe. The timing raised suspicions, with some on X accusing Live Nation of hiring Grenell to curry favor with the Trump administration. This move reeks of cronyism, leveraging his MAGA ties for corporate gain while the Kennedy Center flounders under his watch. Ticket sales have plummeted, and donors are bailing, with reports describing the center as “struggling” under Grenell’s leadership.

Grenell’s claim to be a Christian while allegedly firing Brown for his faith is the cherry on top of this hypocrisy sundae. His marriage to a male spouse doesn’t negate his right to his beliefs, but demanding Brown abandon his biblical convictions to keep his job is a gross overreach. Trump’s vision for the Kennedy Center was to restore “wholesome” entertainment, yet Grenell’s actions—silencing a Christian to appease the media—betray that goal. If Trump is serious about cracking down on anti-Christian bias, he should start by reining in his own appointee. Grenell’s track record of divisive leadership, questionable ethics, and now this apparent betrayal of religious liberty makes one thing clear: he’s more interested in power plays than principles.

Sources:

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/04/18/arts/music/kennedy-center-firings.html

https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/articles/former-kennedy-center-head-denies-192638914.html

https://deadline.com/2025/05/trump-kennedy-center-fraud-investigation-1236406589/

https://www.spiegel.de/international/world/u-s-ambassador-richard-grenell-is-isolated-in-berlin-a-1247610.html

https://www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2020-02-25/richard-grenell-ambassador-germany-acting-director-national-intelligence

https://www.thedailybeast.com/live-nation-hires-trumps-kennedy-center-boss-ric-grenell-amid-doj-probe/

https://www.thedailybeast.com/kennedy-center-boss-wants-to-blacklist-trump-boycotting-stars-of-les-miserables/

https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/live-nation-names-ric-grenell-board-of-directors-trump-ally-1235344483/

https://slate.com/culture/2025/05/kennedy-center-arts-trump-richard-grenell-boycott.html

Why Catholics Should Dismiss the Absurd Claim That Islam Holds Lessons for Happiness

 

A Firm Rejection of U.S. Catholic’s Misguided Comparison

On May 23, 2025, Robert Spencer, known as @jihadwatchRS on X, brought attention to an outlandish article published by U.S. Catholic titled “What Catholics Can Learn from Islam About the Pursuit of Happiness.” Spencer shared the article in a post, linking to his own commentary on Jihad Watch. The U.S. Catholic piece cites the World Happiness Report’s claim that the United States is growing less happy, suggesting that lessons from the Muslim tradition can help. This piece is a baffling mix of theological ignorance, shallow comparisons, and relativistic nonsense that undermines the richness of Catholic doctrine. Faithful Catholics should reject it outright as irrelevant and misguided. Here’s why this claim is not only wrong but an insult to the Catholic faith.

1. Catholic Happiness Is Found in Christ, Not Worldly Metrics

The U.S. Catholic article leans on the World Happiness Report to frame its argument, but this secular metric of happiness—based on subjective well-being and societal factors—has little to do with the Catholic understanding of true joy. Catholicism teaches that happiness, or beatitude, is found in union with Jesus Christ, not in chasing fleeting emotions or borrowing from other faiths. The Beatitudes (Matthew 5:3-12) offer a divine roadmap to eternal fulfillment through virtue and grace. Suggesting that Islam, which denies Christ’s divinity and the salvific power of the Cross, can teach Catholics about happiness is absurd. The article’s reliance on a secular report to justify its premise only highlights its disconnect from Catholic theology.

2. Theological Differences Render the Comparison Ridiculous

Catholicism and Islam are fundamentally incompatible in their views of God, salvation, and the human person. Catholics believe humans are made in God’s image, redeemed by Christ’s sacrifice, and called to eternal life through the sacraments. Islam emphasizes submission to Allah’s will, with no concept of divine sonship or sacramental grace. The U.S. Catholic article’s claim that Catholics can learn from Islamic perspectives on happiness ignores these irreconcilable differences. It’s as if the author thinks spiritual traditions are interchangeable recipes you can mix and match—utterly incoherent and disrespectful.

3. Catholic Practices Are Profound, Not Interchangeable

The article’s suggestion that Catholics adopt Islamic practices like prayer or fasting to enhance their pursuit of happiness is laughable. Catholic prayer, particularly the Eucharist, is a direct encounter with Christ’s real presence, not merely a mindfulness exercise as the article implies about Islamic prayer. Catholic fasting, rooted in penance and union with Christ’s sacrifice, carries a depth that Ramadan’s fasting cannot replicate in a Catholic context. These practices stem from entirely different theologies, making them incompatible. The article’s vague appeal to “shared values” like charity or community is so generic it could apply to any belief system—or none. Catholics already embody these values through the Gospel, with no need to look elsewhere.

4. Relativism Undermines Catholic Truth

The U.S. Catholic article drips with religious relativism, implying that all faiths are equal paths to the same end. This is not just theologically false—it’s a betrayal of the Catholic Church’s claim to the fullness of truth through Christ. By suggesting Catholics can “learn” from Islam’s approach to happiness, the article dismisses the unique role of the Church as the guardian of divine revelation. Catholics profess that Jesus is “the way, the truth, and the life” (John 14:6), not one of many options for personal satisfaction. The article’s failure to uphold this truth renders its arguments irrelevant to any serious Catholic.

5. Shallow Scholarship and Empty Platitudes

The article lacks any serious engagement with Catholic theology or Islamic texts, cherry-picking superficial similarities without referencing the Catechism, Scripture, or the Quran. It tosses around buzzwords like “happiness” without defining them or grounding them in Catholic teaching. The result is a flimsy, feel-good comparison that collapses under scrutiny. Catholics have a 2,000-year tradition of saints, theologians, and mystics who have deeply explored the pursuit of happiness. To claim that Islam offers something novel or superior is not just nonsense—it’s an insult to the Church’s intellectual and spiritual heritage.

6. Syncretism Is a Dangerous Dead End

The article flirts with syncretism, the misguided attempt to blend religions into a spiritual smoothie. This erodes Catholicism’s distinctiveness, which holds that Christ is the sole path to salvation. While interfaith dialogue can promote respect, suggesting Catholics adopt Islamic practices to improve their spiritual lives crosses a line into betrayal. Faithful Catholics should reject this muddled thinking and hold fast to the clarity of their faith, which offers all they need for true happiness.

Conclusion: Toss This Article, Embrace the Faith

The U.S. Catholic article, with its baseless claim that Catholics can learn from Islam about happiness, is a theological trainwreck. Its reliance on the World Happiness Report, shallow comparisons, and relativistic undertones make it utterly dismissible. Catholics have a rich, Christ-centered understanding of happiness rooted in Scripture, tradition, and the sacraments. There’s no need to scavenge ideas from another faith, especially one that fundamentally differs in its view of God and salvation. Skip this article and turn to the Gospels, the saints, or the Catechism for true guidance on eternal joy. Anything else is just noise.